The Crime Dilemma: The Rise of Private Security in Latin America

 

 

 

Criminal violence in Latin America has reached epidemic proportions despite gains in poverty reduction, education, health and overall living standards. The response of many governments, corporations, and the wealthy has been to invest heavily in private security, often to the detriment of public security and human rights. This trend has given rise to a booming private security industry that remains largely unregulated and has accelerated the proliferation of weapons.

 

According to a report last year by the Inter-AmericanDialogue, over 16,000 Private Military and Security Companies (PMSCs) employ an estimated 2.4 million people in Latin America. The number of private security guards outnumbers police in Latin America more than anywhere else in the world. For example, in Brazil, the ratio of private security to police is four to one, in Guatemala five to one, and in Honduras there are almost seven private guards for every police officer. Of course, this has translated into security for the privileged few and the masses left to fend for themselves.

 

 

• According to data from the Brazilian think tank Igarapé Institute, 33% of all homicides in the world occur in Latin America, the region only accounts for 8% of the world’s population

 

• 17 of the 20 countries with the highest homicide rates are in Latin America

 

• Brazil, Colombia, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico and Venezuela account for one-quarter of all intentional homicides* globally each year

 

• 43 out of the world’s 50 most violent cities are located in the region

 

• For every 100,000 inhabitants in Latin America, 21 are murdered – the world average is seven

 

• In the last decade, the homicide rate in Latin America increased 3.7%, and the population by only 1.1%

 

 

 

 

 

The ‘inequality of security’

 

The violence in the region most affects primarily poor youth. A study of youth violence in the region found that young males living in low-income areas have a one in 50 chance of being killed before they reach the age of 31. Moreover, over half of the 25 countries with the highest rates of femicide in the world are in Latin America and the Caribbean. Similarly, most of these female victims are poor and young. Impunity prevails in most of these cases and conviction rates are pitifully low. In North America and Europe, roughly 80% of all homicides result in conviction, but in Latin America it is only 20%.

 

 

 

 

The ‘PMSC industrial complex’

 

Consequently, people of the region have become disillusioned with law enforcement and the criminal justice system in general. For those who can afford it, with the rise in crime and violence so has the demand for private security skyrocketed. For example, according to InSight Crime, in Mexico with record high levels of violence and homicides, and where the police forces are infamously corrupt and ineffective, the private security industry has grown 180% since 2012 and is now worth $1.5 billion.

 

 

 

 

 

The severe limitations, and even perverse consequences, of the private security model have been well documented. Last year’s report released by the Inter-AmericanDialogue highlights the following:

 

• Every Latin American country has laws for the registration and regulation of PMSCs, but they do not enforce them

 

• The ‘PMSC industrial complex’ – Many working in the sector are former members of the military and police and therefore there are often close ties between private security firms, the government, and security forces resulting in corruption, favoritism in contracting, and political influence

 

• The ‘inequality of security’ – “Wealthy businesses and individuals spend on their individual security while often paying little in taxes that would fund the collective security that would benefit society at large. Meanwhile, the industry takes qualified personnel from government security forces, leaving them understaffed and forced to hire and train less experienced personnel”

 

• The industry a “major supplier” of weapons to criminal groups. According to the report, 40% of illegal firearms in El Salvador are connected to the country’s roughly 500 private security companies

 

• The rise in private military and security companies has contributed to corruption and human rights violations, especially in the extractive industries that prevail over many economies in the region

 

 

 

 

‘Selective security, uncertainty and more violence’

 

Insecurity and violence have led to profits for PMSCs in Latin America. However, it has resulted in what Jenny Pearce at the LSE Latin America Centre has identified as “selective security, uncertainty (insecurity), and more violence”. However, what equally may be of most danger, given the growth of PMCs, is its negative incentive to invest in public security. Adam Blackwell from the Development Services Group got it part right last year when he noted “in most cases, the private security companies do not want public security — they have no incentive to contribute to it.” More precisely, they may even be incentivized by more insecurity.

 

 

 

* Intentional homicide means killing a human being willfully and illegally. That means the intent was to cause death or serious injury, but not necessarily that it was planned beforehand.

 

 

 

 

Image: Candelario Gomez Lopez / Pixabay (link)

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Grey Dynamics LTD.