Confidential

Cryptography: Cryptowars During the Cold War

Cryptography is the practice of communicating securely between two parties. Cryptographers used techniques to ensure only the sender and intended recipient can process and read the content.

Perhaps the most famous example of cryptography and cryptoanalysis is the German Enigma cipher in 1941. The breakthrough meant that new and more complex cryptography techniques needed to be developed. The objective was to ensure interceptors could not understand the information sent. As a result, cryptography developed significantly during the Cold War era. This article examines key breakthroughs in this technology during the Cold War period.

Cryptography: So what?

Cryptography methods form the basis of modern cryptography in the computer age. Therefore, it is important to understand the origins of this technology.

Cryptography Methodology

Cryptography machines such as the Enigma used variants of the following process:

  1. The sender types their message into the machine.

  2. The keyboard is linked to three or four rotors that transpose each keystroke. The starting position of each rotor determines this key.

  3. Each time a user presses a key, the rotors move one notch.

  4. More advanced encryption machines had a plugboard (in German: Steckerbrett) which further encrypted the message.

  5. Once the user types the message the machine sents it to the receiver in morse code.

  6. The sender would decrypt the message using their knowledge of the sender’s settings.

Generally, senders would change the settings on the encryption machine daily. The information as to the setting of the sender’s encryption settings was sent to the receiver separately via a trusted messenger by hand, to ensure only they would have the key to unlock the messages. This was both lengthy in terms of getting the message to the intended recipient and was open to issues with human error.

Cryptography
(Img; Typical cryptographic machine methodology; via The Guardian)

During WW2, Britain focused on cryptoanalysis and had large resources and numbers of personnel dedicated to decoding adversaries’ encrypted messages. However, during the final years of WW2 and the start of the Cold War, GCHQ (then GC&CS) shifted its focus towards the development of newer, more secure communication technologies.

US and British Developments

Cryptography
(Img; C block at GCHQ’s old Oakley site in Cheltenham; via GCHQ)

During the Cold War, the UK developed their existing cryptography and cryptoanalysis capabilities significantly. Between 1947 and 1970, Britain introduced four advanced cryptography machines: Typex, Rockex, Noreen and Alvis. Methods developed during WW2 largely built the development of these new cipher machines. The use of more rotors increased their complexity. In this way, cryptoanalysis of any intercepted messages was far more challenging.

In particular, British Embassies and government officials used the Rockex machine, and its successor Rockex II, from 1943 well into the 1970s. The UK Intelligence requested to develop Rockex. The Rockex machine built on existing technology of its predecessor, the Telekryton. It was to be much smaller and easier to use than previous machines. Similarly, it allowed for longer and more secure messaging.

Cryptography
(Img; Rockex Cryptography machine; via Crypto Museum)

Rockex I and Rockex II did have some security weaknesses which were resolved in later versions (IV and V). As a result, in 1955, NATO approved latter versions of Rockex for use for COSMIC secret traffic, indicating the level of security the machine offered.

A New Soviet Frontier: M-125 Fialka

The Soviet Union developed the Fialka machine in the final years of WW2 and introduced the Fialka into widespread Intelligence use in 1956. The Fialka was a great step forward for Soviet cryptography, however was based on existing technology.

Cryptography
(Img; M-125 Machine, aka Fialka cryptography machine; via Crypto Museum)

The Fialka machine was far more complicated than the machines used by Soviet forces in WW2 as it had ten rotating wheels rather than previous models’ three or four. This meant that intercepted messages would be far more challenging and time-consuming to decode.

Ciphers created by the Fialka machine were almost impossible to decipher by manual means. Military historian Stephen Budiansky has argued that these ciphers have only been broken through human error, rather than a security deficiency with the machine.

“The significant breaks that both [the United States] and the Soviets made throughout the Cold War in each other’s systems came either through ‘direct’ means,” such as stealing key lists of codes, “or blunders in procedures that gave away crucial details about the internal scrambling patterns of the coding systems.” –

Stephen Budiansky

The Fialka was significant in terms of communications technology as it allowed for more secure communication. It also only required one operator rather than previous models which have required two.

Whilst the Fialka was used extensively during the Cold War by Soviet forces, the existence of the device was not declassified until 2005. Therefore, cryptography during the Cold War is still an evolving field of study.

What’s Next?

The rising tensions caused by the Cold War meant that both Soviet forces, as well as the US and its allies, saw a need to develop their cryptography systems. Both the examples of the Rockex machine and the Fialka machine show that developed quickly and significantly during this period and developments during this period formed the basis of modern computer-age encryption methods.

Author

Abbi Clark

Abbi is a graduate in Chinese Studies from the University of Nottingham, specialising in Asian politics and International Relations. She is currently studying MA Intelligence & Security Studies at Brunel University London. Her research interests focus on geopolitics and modern defense issues.

Leave a Reply

No Comments Yet!